Definition: Now Moses in the law commanded us, that such should be stoned: but what sayest thou?
Explanation: Okay, let’s break down that passage from John 8:5. It's a really important and slightly tricky verse, and it gets to the heart of how Jesus challenges religious tradition. Here’s a simple explanation: The Basic Idea: This verse is asking Jesus about the idea that God gave Moses laws – rules for people to follow – and then later, some people started stoning others because they didn't obey those laws. Let's unpack it further: “Now Moses in the law commanded us…” This part refers to a time when Moses was giving instructions about how people should behave. He was setting a standard for morality and rules. “…that such should be stoned:…” This is where the problem starts. The phrase "stoned" means to be severely beaten or killed with violence. It’s a very harsh punishment. Jesus is saying this wasn't the right way to deal with following these laws. “But what sayest thou?” This is a rhetorical question, meaning Jesus is asking you to respond. He’s essentially inviting you to share your thoughts. So, what does Jesus mean by this? Jesus is saying that the Jewish people (and perhaps even many people at the time) were interpreting and applying Moses' laws in a very harsh and violent way. They were focusing on punishment rather than love and understanding. He’s challenging them to consider if their interpretation of these laws was truly just and compassionate. The Core Message: Jesus is pointing out that true obedience isn't about fear of punishment, but about loving God and others. It’s about showing compassion and forgiveness, not about inflicting harm. He wants us to think beyond simply following rules for our own benefit to actually understand the meaning of those laws and live a life of goodness. In short, Jesus is saying, "Don't just blindly obey rules; be kind and compassionate." --- Do you want me to: Explain another verse from John 8? Discuss the context of this passage in more detail? Give you a real-life example of how this principle applies today?